I recall a
conversation in Zanzibar with a Tanzanian professor from a Canadian university
who was researching China’s role in Africa.
That was in 2010 and as I leave Niger I see once again China’s influence
and affluence here as I have seen it in most other African countries I have
worked in.
Niger is one of the
ten poorest countries in the world and its main natural resource is
uranium. This is currently mined by
Areva, a large French conglomerate (partly owned by the French government), and
more recently by Somina, a Chinese owned mine in Azalik, Northern Niger.
Generally, unlike
most Western governments, when pursuing business interests, the Chinese work
with whatever government is in power. They provide loans and infrastructure in
return for natural resources that they need with no political strings attached
relating to democracy, transparency, or human rights. This 'non-interference' model gives African
leaders more freedom and the opportunity to work for immediate economic development.
For western
governments this approach seems to threaten the promotion of democracy,
transparency, liberalism and free trade, that western governments are so keen
to encourage engaging perhaps in economic development at the expense of civil
progress, and strengthened ties between political and economic elites over of
broad social change.
I
have recently finished reading Dambisa Moyo (Zambian economist) recent book
‘How the West was lost’ in which she comments on a subject close to my heart;
the hypocrisy of western governments who accuse the Chinese government of
meddling in free-market capitalism, while forgetting that US farm subsidy
programmes and Europe's Common Agricultural Policy condemn Africa's farmers to
poverty.
She
suggests that the West gained its wealth through invading and plundering the
rest of the world, whereas China is engaging on transparent business terms with
countries that want to sell their resources.
Clearly
the US is happy to take China's money (the majority of US debt is held by the
Chinese) yet somehow the US, UK and others expect a higher standard from
developing countries.
I
don’t know whether China’s investment in Africa is always a good thing but the
traditional western aid model with strings attached hasn’t helped lift people
out of poverty and while I’m not naïve enough to suggest that the ‘China in
Africa’ model will, I’m prepared to believe that it can help.
No comments:
Post a Comment