Saturday, 12 February 2011

Education for Everyone

So let me give you a little but of the context in North Kivu.  The conflict in Eastern Congo is a long standing conflict that changes shape from time to time.  The conflict environment is increasingly fractured despite elections in 2006 and North Kivu–based peace accords in 2008 and 2009. While some areas remain insecure, others have now been judged safe for return, and the process of rebuilding homes and communities has begun for many of the people who were formerly displaced by fighting. 

In Masisi territory, one of the areas where we work, throughout 2010 there have been a high number of returnees coming back to the area putting pressure on the health, education, and water and sanitation resources.   Our projects try to ease this pressure on support services and to ensure that children in the area are protected.
Part of our integrated project focuses on the provision of education for children.  Education provides stability for children who have been through the trauma of displacement, loss and sometimes abuse.  Children in this area are often at particular risk of recruitment into armed forces and former child soldiers or those at risk of recruitment benefit from an emergency Accelerated Learning intervention, as education is recognised as a key means of providing protection for children in conflict zones.

The Accelerated Learning Program and the support to schools reinforces children’s survival skills by inclusion of topics such as sexual violence, HIV/AIDS, and non-violence.  Teachers are trained both in pedagogical aspects of ALP and in offering psychosocial support to children who have experienced difficulty, even trauma, making such programmes particularly appropriate for former child soldiers.

Jean-Pierre, the director of one of the supported schools, recognises many impacts of this work.  The numbers of children attending school have increased; children are able to study better with new equipment, desks and books; and the COPA (parents’ committee), formed to manage the school’s funds, has received training in better management of the school.

Teachers work hard but often don’t get their paltry government salary.  A primary school teacher’s salary is around £30 a month.  Salaries  have become a bigger problem since the government announced in late August 2010 that the first three years of primary schooling would be free for all children (outside of Kinshasa and Lubumbashi; it will take longer to implement in the big cities). Free education will be scaled up in 2011-2012 to include free education for the last three years of primary school. 

Unfortunately while the announcement shows good intentions in terms of the President’s political commitments it wasn’t backed up with any clear plan and so unsurprisingly there were problems.  Parents in most areas refused to pay fees for their children because they had heard that it should be free but of course the government hadn’t yet committed any funds to cover the basic resources that were usually covered by the school fees.  This includes the salary that teachers like Jean Pierre receive for working and finances for books, and maintenance of the school building.  And so the end result was that many children did not go to school until teachers agreed to work for free and wait for their government salary.

Hopefully in the coming year government will put its weight behind the programme to really make a difference to the education of it’s children.

Sunday, 6 February 2011

Confused

I had a rather strange conversation this week that made me question my somewhat poor French communication skills.
The conversation with the radio operator went something like this:
Me:  my radio is not working
Him:  you should charge it
Me:  it is charged but it’s not working
Him:  let me take it and check the battery
[2 hours later]
Him:  you’re right it’s not working; the battery is fine but it’s not working
Me:  okay… can you give me another one
Him:  There’s no other one; just use this one
[He leaves]
I am supposed to be responsible for security and monitor the radio 24/7 but I don’t have a working radio… in the end it was easier to borrow a working one from another colleague than to pursue the radio operator.
It does beg the question is it me or are we somehow just not managing to communicate with each other.  In the meantime I will try to get to the bottom of the problem and continue with adding more French to my vocabulary.

I realise that my posts this week are a bit dry and will try to send a more interesting post next week once I actually get to the field sites to see some of our projects.

The Frustrations of Pooled Funds

So, as luck would have it I arrived in DRC for a short assignment just in time for the Pooled Funding process (equivalent of the CHF in Sudan).  For those of you who work in the humanitarian world you will know just what a nightmare this is for the average NGO worker responsible for securing funds for their organisation. You will also know that it’s the time of year when the fists come out and lines are drawn; it’s every man for himself and the UN is the most powerful ‘man’ in the process.  For those who don’t know, let me enlighten you…
These pooled funding mechanisms are basically a pool of money from various donors that issupposed to be available for urgent humanitarian needs.  The funds are donated by major donor governments (the US and EC so far have thankfully not engaged in the pooled funding) and managed by UNDP.  On an annual basis once the total pot of money is committed NGOs and UN agencies submit their requests for funding.  Decisions on who gets what are done through the ‘clusters’ (a UN name for the various sectors – water, health, education, protection etc).  The clusters are led by the relevant UN agency.  Apart from the various issues about what can and can’t be funded the main issue in the allocations process is that the UN agencies who eventually decide on the allocations benefit disproportionately from the funds.   (For those not in the business UN agencies don’t actually implement projects.)  They fund and support NGOs to implement projects for them.  So this money that is allocated to, for example, Unicef is then further disbursed to an NGO to implement the project with Unicef taking a large cut for administration rather than giving the money direct to an NGO in the first place. 
There are a number of other pooled funds managed by the World Bank and other managing agents and the problem with most of these funds is that the donors (led by my own government) are more interested in shifting the money off their books than what it actually goes to.  Normally a person can demand a better service for the money they pay for something but in the aid industry the person receiving the service is not the person paying for the service and there are many middle men in between.       
Donors and the people/taxpayers behind them pay for goods or services that they will not receive benefit from and so tend not to care as much about whether it is delivered in a timely manner and to the quality expected.  In most cases the people who should actually receive the goods or services paid for don’t actually know that these things have been bought for them and so the middle men (fund managers – mostly the UN and the World Bank) have little interest in delivering these things in a timely manner and so some funds sit in New York gaining a huge amount interest (sometimes for years) before they are spent.  Some have limited time frames on them but in most cases donors who give to the UN or the World Bank write off this money as being disbursed long before it actually goes to the people it was originally intended for. 
With funds given as bilateral grants to NGOs there is a fair amount of evaluation as to how the money has been spent but this costs the donor time and money in managing the grant given and so the preference is becoming the Pooled Fund system as once the money is given to the UN or the World Bank and the donor writes it off their books as being spent.  Donors should care about how their money is being spent but sadly care more about how much they spend rather than what it is spent on.  I do hope that one day the recipients of aid will begin to act in a way that demands better management of this money that is for them.
Let me get off my high horse now and get back to the mundane fact that my life for the next two weeks will be all about the meetings that will no doubt be planned with a few hours notice, proposals that will have to be written with less that a days notice and there will be no limit to the amount of confusion about the process between the various actors.  Hopefully at the end of day we’ll have more funding for important projects in protection, education and health.