Sunday, 22 July 2012

Monetization



Monetization is not a word I had come across prior to working in Niger.  We applied for and received a large 5 year grant from ‘Food for Peace’ a branch of USAID.  However, most of this grant comes from the process of monetisation.  Put simply, monetization is the process of converting or establishing something into legal tender and in US Agricultural Policy it refers to the process of donating surplus US grain stocks to an NGO (like Save the Children) who inn turn sell them locally in order to gain funds that can then be used for our proposed agriculture projects. 

Food Aid itself can be controversial; while there is no doubt that giving food to malnourished and starving populations assists and often saves lives it is equally true that long term food distributions in chronic and complex emergencies can harm local production and markets, undermining long-term food security and serving as a pawn in the broader battle for resources in conflict torn countries. Food aid is also rarely the most efficient use of resources for alleviating poverty, hence the rise of cash transfers in recent years.

Monetization is economically inefficient; procuring food in the US, transporting it overseas, and then selling it locally (after the hassle of importing it to the country) in order to generate funds for food security programs is clear far less cost-effective than the simple alternative –providing money to fund food security programs.  But this wouldn’t help American farmers who depend on US government subsidies to grow a surplus which is then bought back by the government for just this purpose.

Monetization normally involves open-market sale of commodities to generate cash, it inevitably causes commercial displacement and can therefore be harmful to traders and local farmers, undermining the development of local markets, which is detrimental to longer-term food security objectives.


Others donors who previously used monetization  have since stopped – principally the EU and WFP but the US continue to contribute development aid funds in this manner though some NGOs like CARE and Oxfam refuse to receive monetisation funds now putting pressure on the US government to stop this practice as well.  

Proponents of the monetization process (the US Government) argue that it increases the quality and quantity of food available in the recipient country and can develop markets and stabilize local food prices, however long term use of this process as we have seen actually displaces imports on the competitive market, disrupts local markets and leads to a dependency on aid without achieving the principle objectives of projects funded in this manner namely to achieve sustainable food security for the recipient population.

The USAID Food for Peace Manual actually states , “Monetization is … available to enhance the food security of vulnerable households through the use of U.S. food commodities. Monetization also creates opportunities for American businesses to produce, process, and ship in-kind food aid.”  Which says it all...

1. A food aid warehouse in Ethiopia
2. Children queuing for food in Niger

1 comment: