Thursday, 8 November 2012

Liberia Liberated?



On November 8, 2005, Liberian women had cause for jubilation: Ellen Johnson Sirleaf, the first female African  President was elected.  A country weary from fourteen years of civil war, women across the country had responded overwhelmingly to Sirleaf's rallying cry: "All the men have failed Liberia; let's try a woman this time!" Promising to bring a "motherly sensitivity and emotion to the presidency," Ellen Johnson Sirleaf won a commanding victory to beat former football star George Weah by nearly 20%.

So how is Liberia progressing 7 years on?  Has Africa’s first female President delivered? 

Apart from allegations that she once supported Charles Taylor and a recommendation from the TRC that she not be elegible to stand for public office for 30 years as a result of this, she has begun to rebuild the country but progress is slow.
Many feel that while she has little to show in terms of progress from her first term in office at least the country is not fighting.  There are criticisms of her failure to address corruption, decentralisation and national reconciliation.  Concern being raised that women in politics suffer the same ‘Big Man’ syndrome suffered by men in power when 2 of her sons were appointed to prominent roles, one as chairman of the national oil company and another as Deputy Governor of the Bank of Liberia.
A former Minister of Finance, the Harvard education Johnson Sirleaf worked in economics for the World Bank and the UN and has at least ensured stability and the rule of law, managed to pull off large scale bilateral and multilateral debt forgiveness putting the country on a sound financial footing and as a result foreign investment is gradually beginning to trickle in.
In 2011 Liberia hosted leaders from more than 40 conflict-affected and fragile countries, international partners and civil society organisations in the second meeting of the ‘International Dialogue on Peacebuilding and Statebuilding’ and this was a turning point.  For these countries the attainment of the millennium development goals are a dream - not a single low-income fragile state is likely to achieve any of them soon. This conference agreed that before the MDGs there needed to be a new focus on peacebuilding and statebuilding; looking at political settlements, security, justice, jobs, growth, revenues and services.
The overarching priority has to be a focus on ensuring people are secure in their communities; abuses are addressed through fair legal processes; jobs are created for young people, former combatants and female headed households; natural resources are a factor of growth and not a cause of conflict.
These are the Monrovia peacebuilding and statebuilding objectives. It's an ambitious set of goals, but as the Liberian president, Ellen Johnson Sirleaf, pointed out, "the challenges are huge, but they're not bigger than the challenges we've faced in the past".

Wednesday, 31 October 2012

Liberia Lighting




Arriving in Monrovia I naturally make comparisons to the many other African cities.  On the west coast of Africa, Monrovia is a wet, humid city which stretches along a beautiful coastline but Monrovia, like most cities is one of contrasts. The airport is some 40km from the city and on approaching the city I was pleasantly surprised by the solar street lights lining the road on the drive in from the airport.  Solar makes a lot of sense in much of Africa – more so than in Scotland for obvious reasons. 
Talking to Save the Children staff in Monrovia though, I’m told that there remains a significant power supply problem.  Most of the city, including poorer areas and slums, used to have access to the electricity grid. After the end of 14 years in civil war, the entire country was in the dark and now nearly 10 years later many areas remain so despite President Sirleaf’s commitment to restore power.  The hotel I’m staying in at the moment is powered by a noisy generator pumping smelly diesel-powered electricity in the atmosphere and few can afford such luxury. 
Makeshift wires hang dangerously low from the tightly packed concrete homes and tin shacks – the product of entrepreneurs in communities who sell their electricity on. After dark, criminality thrives undercover of darkness in these areas that have no access to electricity.  School children can’t do their homework and there is little to occupy restless unemployed young people. 
I’m told that before the war Liberia's energy supply relied heavily on the hydropower plant at Mount Coffee, 30km north-east of Monrovia which like most infrastructure was destroyed in the fighting.  Despite the commitment of Ellen Johnson Sirleaf to restore power to Liberia there remains a lot to be done with apparently less than 1% of Monrovians having access to the grid since it was re-established in 2010.  Liberia has an energy target to connect 30% of the country's urban population and 15% of the rural population to the national grid by 2015 which seems a tall order given the current rate of growth. 
Listening to Save the Children staff talk about their experiences during the civil war humbles me.  People have such resilience and find ways to cope with the greatest of tragedies and while electricity may seem a luxury in a place with on-going conflict, underemployment, food crises poor access to healthcare and education, electricity brings with it development and above all security for a population who have been through so much.  Let’s hope Liberia meets its 2015 target and that solar power to rural areas become more affordable.

Preparing for Emergencies in Liberia



I’ve been here in Monrovia for a few weeks to facilitate operations and emergency response training for our team here and am currently stuck in a hotel, my flight having been cancelled. 

A brief history lesson:  Liberia is one of 2 sub-Saharan African countries that was never formally colonised, though it suffered many of the same effects of colonisation, by the freed slaves from the US who created it as a country in 1847.  Its capital city, Monrovia was named for America’s 5th President, James Monroe who was a strong supporter of giving freed slaves a homeland.

The US has continued to be one of the greatest investors in Liberia and following the second world war US investment and economic liberalisation meant that Liberia grew at comparably strong rate.  The lack of political liberalisation though resulted in a coup in 1980 by Samuel Doe and two successive civil wars (including the one where Charles Taylor traded blood diamonds in support of Sierra Leone’s civil war) followed leaving over 250,000 people dead and devastating the country’s economy.  A peace agreement in 2003 led to democratic elections for the first time and Ellen Johnson Sirleaf became President in 2006.

Since then, though the country has had little time to rebuild itself with severe flooding across West Africa in 2007, a caterpillar infestations destroyed crops across the north of the country n 2009, religious fighting in the north between Muslims and Christians in 2010, and in 2011 borders on the south-east flooded with refugees from Cote d’Ivoire and the post-election violence there stretching weak health care systems even further.

In our Emergency Preparedness planning workshop we looked at the many factors that continue to be a real threat to long term security here. Violence and conflict can erupt so easily when an already vulnerable population are hit by yet another shock plunging them even further into desperate poverty.  The remnants of the civil wars and years of neglect are evident even now some 6 years after democratically free elections.  Destruction is caused so easily, by conflict, drought, flood, corruption but it takes years to rebuild.

Thursday, 30 August 2012

China in Africa



I recall a conversation in Zanzibar with a Tanzanian professor from a Canadian university who was researching China’s role in Africa.  That was in 2010 and as I leave Niger I see once again China’s influence and affluence here as I have seen it in most other African countries I have worked in.
Niger is one of the ten poorest countries in the world and its main natural resource is uranium.  This is currently mined by Areva, a large French conglomerate (partly owned by the French government), and more recently by Somina, a Chinese owned mine in Azalik, Northern Niger. 
Generally, unlike most Western governments, when pursuing business interests, the Chinese work with whatever government is in power.  They provide loans and infrastructure in return for natural resources that they need with no political strings attached relating to democracy, transparency, or human rights.  This 'non-interference' model gives African leaders more freedom and the opportunity to work for immediate economic development.
For western governments this approach seems to threaten the promotion of democracy, transparency, liberalism and free trade, that western governments are so keen to encourage engaging perhaps in economic development at the expense of civil progress, and strengthened ties between political and economic elites over of broad social change.
I have recently finished reading Dambisa Moyo (Zambian economist) recent book ‘How the West was lost’ in which she comments on a subject close to my heart; the hypocrisy of western governments who accuse the Chinese government of meddling in free-market capitalism, while forgetting that US farm subsidy programmes and Europe's Common Agricultural Policy condemn Africa's farmers to poverty.  
She suggests that the West gained its wealth through invading and plundering the rest of the world, whereas China is engaging on transparent business terms with countries that want to sell their resources. 
Clearly the US is happy to take China's money (the majority of US debt is held by the Chinese) yet somehow the US, UK and others expect a higher standard from developing countries. 
I don’t know whether China’s investment in Africa is always a good thing but the traditional western aid model with strings attached hasn’t helped lift people out of poverty and while I’m not naïve enough to suggest that the ‘China in Africa’ model will, I’m prepared to believe that it can help.

Sunday, 22 July 2012

Monetization



Monetization is not a word I had come across prior to working in Niger.  We applied for and received a large 5 year grant from ‘Food for Peace’ a branch of USAID.  However, most of this grant comes from the process of monetisation.  Put simply, monetization is the process of converting or establishing something into legal tender and in US Agricultural Policy it refers to the process of donating surplus US grain stocks to an NGO (like Save the Children) who inn turn sell them locally in order to gain funds that can then be used for our proposed agriculture projects. 

Food Aid itself can be controversial; while there is no doubt that giving food to malnourished and starving populations assists and often saves lives it is equally true that long term food distributions in chronic and complex emergencies can harm local production and markets, undermining long-term food security and serving as a pawn in the broader battle for resources in conflict torn countries. Food aid is also rarely the most efficient use of resources for alleviating poverty, hence the rise of cash transfers in recent years.

Monetization is economically inefficient; procuring food in the US, transporting it overseas, and then selling it locally (after the hassle of importing it to the country) in order to generate funds for food security programs is clear far less cost-effective than the simple alternative –providing money to fund food security programs.  But this wouldn’t help American farmers who depend on US government subsidies to grow a surplus which is then bought back by the government for just this purpose.

Monetization normally involves open-market sale of commodities to generate cash, it inevitably causes commercial displacement and can therefore be harmful to traders and local farmers, undermining the development of local markets, which is detrimental to longer-term food security objectives.


Others donors who previously used monetization  have since stopped – principally the EU and WFP but the US continue to contribute development aid funds in this manner though some NGOs like CARE and Oxfam refuse to receive monetisation funds now putting pressure on the US government to stop this practice as well.  

Proponents of the monetization process (the US Government) argue that it increases the quality and quantity of food available in the recipient country and can develop markets and stabilize local food prices, however long term use of this process as we have seen actually displaces imports on the competitive market, disrupts local markets and leads to a dependency on aid without achieving the principle objectives of projects funded in this manner namely to achieve sustainable food security for the recipient population.

The USAID Food for Peace Manual actually states , “Monetization is … available to enhance the food security of vulnerable households through the use of U.S. food commodities. Monetization also creates opportunities for American businesses to produce, process, and ship in-kind food aid.”  Which says it all...

1. A food aid warehouse in Ethiopia
2. Children queuing for food in Niger

Friday, 15 June 2012

Niger's Mothers



Save the Children US published its annual State of the World’s Mothers report at the end of May in which Niger was deemed the worst place in the world to be a Mother – last year it was Afghanistan.  This came as a surprise to those of us working in Niger, and indeed to the government of Niger.

Since arriving here last month I have been impressed by the government and the people in this landlocked country in the middle of the Sahara desert.  With conflict in Libya to the North, in Chad to the East, in Mali to the West and in northern Nigeria to the South, Niger is a surprisingly calm and peaceful place.  The current food crisis is severe but the government took action early on and so the impact is not expected to be as bad as it was in 2005 or 2010.

Why then is Niger thought to be the worst place in the world to be a mother?

The State of the World’s Mothers report compares conditions for mothers in 165 countries around the globe, looking at factors such as mother's health, education and economic status, as well as critical child indicators such as health and nutrition.  Infant nutrition as well as maternal nutrition are key in developing a child’s mental and physical development.

Niger, despite its recent improvements in governance, is an exceptionally poor country.  The majority of its 15 million people live well below the poverty line.  In the report Niger performs very poorly across all indicators of maternal and child health and well-being. Levels of maternal mortality and education, contraceptive use, women’s income relative to men’s, as well as primary school enrolment and rates of child malnutrition are among the very worst in the world.

Malnutrition is an underlying cause of 2.6 million child deaths each year.  Millions more children survive, but suffer lifelong physical and cognitive impairments because they didn’t get the nutrients they needed early in their lives when their growing bodies and minds were most vulnerable. When children start their lives malnourished, the negative effects are largely irreversible.  Therefore, good nutrition in the first 3 years of a child’s life not only impacts the child’s health and ability to grow and learn but clearly also has an economic impact if that child grows into a productive adult.

In the same report Norway was deemed to be the best place to be a mother with Australia at 7th, UK coming in 10th and US at 25th.

Thursday, 31 May 2012

Sahel Crisis


Once again the countries across the Sahel are facing a drought.  This is beginning of the rainy season and it’s not raining yet and while there is still hope that it will and planting has begun, the results of last years poor harvest are now being felt in what is known as the ‘hunger gap’.  I am on my way to Niger to oversee Save the Children’s emergency response and wanted to write something now in the relative cool and calm of Dakar before I travel as I know things are about to become ‘busy’.

Niger is one of the poorest of the countries that comprise the Sahel, countries that stretch from Senegal to Sudan bounded by the Sahara desert to the north.  Food insecurity and malnutrition are chronic in Niger, but things this year are worse; for the third time in seven years, this region has been especially hard hit by poor rains and low agriculture yields that have left a mind-boggling 16 million people across the Sahel without sufficient food.

Compounding the drought related problems across Niger are the problems in Mali, it’s neighbour to the West.  In Western Niger there are over 40,000 Malian refugees.  Mali destablised when Tuareg separatist groups, having returned well-armed from Libya, mounted a rebellion in northern Mali.  The arrival of displaced Malian’s obviously puts additional pressure on already scarce resources in Niger.  

Save the Children currently work in 3 locations in Niger and have done so since 2005 in response to another drought that faced the country.  One of the key problems has been the reliance on emergency (short term) funding which helps to solve the immediate needs of a population in crisis but will never help them build resilience to future crises. There is clearly a recurrence of climate-related disasters in the Sahel, notwithstanding political problems in some countries.  The fact that such crises are recurring on a more frequent basis leaves local populations with less time to recover before the next crisis comes.  There is clearly a need for longer term donor funding in order to increase the “resilience” of vulnerable populations to withstand and rebound from more frequent climate extremes and we need to work on persuading donors of this while responding to the current crisis.  Then perhaps such responses won’t be needed in the future.

Sunday, 27 May 2012

All is well in JaneLand


So it’s been a while since I last wrote anything meaningful on this blog and it’s been a very pleasant while!  I last wrote from South Sudan where I seem to have been working rather more than I intended.  Since leaving South Sudan at the beginning of April I have visited good friends in Uganda; studied a bit (and sat an exam for my MBA); been on holiday to Berlin where the weather was glorious and company better; I climbed Arthur’s Seat for the first time; and at home I have recovered a chair in my flat, had carpets relaid in all the bedrooms and painted one of the bedrooms.  I also voted in the local council elections where a man dressed as a penguin (Professor Pongu) got more votes than the Lib Dems…

Workwise I spent a bit of time in the London office, I prepared training materials for Save the Children partners in Somalia and then plans changed and I’m now in Dakar en route to Niger for 3-4 months. 

All in all though, it’s been a lovely 6 weeks of holiday, working from home, spending time with friends and family and enjoying the rarity of Edinburgh sunshine.
While I was at home Dad had a triple bypass and seems to be recovering well from it and so all is well with my world.  

All is not so well in the Sahel region of Africa though… more about that another time...

Wednesday, 14 March 2012

KONY2012 and its absurdity

A week ago, ‘Invisible Children’ released their KONY2012 video and it went ‘viral’ as they say, which in itself is quite remarkable; very rarely is the western world’s conscious so well awakened by an African conflict.  
I have been astonished by some of the positive comments on facebook and other fora about this and equally relieved by other comments in criticism of Invisible Children’s plan in response to the LRA crisis that spans across Northern Uganda, South Sudan, DRC and CAR.
I certainly don't claim to be an expert and others have written critical responses to the KONY2012 video.  This issue has made me sufficiently angry though that it has compelled me to put pen to paper.
Joseph Kony is a fugitive and maintains this existence through keeping a low profile, moving on foot through forests and areas that are severly underdeveloped and keeping people fearful of him.  He has rejected numerous peace deals and while his works are atrocious relatively speaking (in terms of people he has killed or abducted) he is no worse than many of South Sudan’s rebel leaders, yet he is internationally known, and feared and the media have perpetuated this. As Alex de Waal says, he has ‘an impressively high infamy-to-atrocity ratio testament to the effectiveness of terrorist advertising’.
Invisible Children’s campaign which advocates the use of American military ‘advisors’ to support the local armies of Uganda, South Sudan and Congo is somewhat deluded given successive military attempts to capture Kony over the years.  He has been under an ICC arrest warrant since 2006 and has so far evaded it.  The last time the Ugandan Army (with their colleagues, the Rwandans) entered Congo to catch the genocidaires hundreds of civilians were killed, villages were burnt and women raped.  
Since peace and stability began returning to northern Uganda over the last 6-8 years (when Kony left the area) reconstruction and reconciliation projects have been in place. Kony and his LRA have survived in this region principally because the people in these areas have reasons to distrust the national government and rule of law doesn’t extend this far.  Kony has moved out of northern Uganda as the country has stabilised but he remains active in South Sudan, CAR and DRC. 
I am certain that a man hunt for someone who has been driven from his own country, through the use of increase military spending across sovereign borders is not a beneficial solution to the problem of the LRA.  In the same way that the removal of Sadaam Hussein from Iraq did not bring peace, and the removal of Osama Bin Laden has not stopped Al-Quaida, stopping Kony will not stop the LRA unless something else changes in the region.  Kony has been driven from Northern Uganda, for the most part, by investment in infrastructure, stronger government interest and community development.  
The links between poverty and conflict are strong and economically independent,, educated, healthy people are much less likely to take up arms and fight.  If you have nothing to lose and everything to gain by fighting it’s a sensible option to take and surely the way to drive people like Kony to obscurity is to continue to develop investment in communities and their children, through education, through economic empowerment and development of social and physical infrastructure.  It’s a cliché but, by building stronger, more resilient communities that have access to basic services, many of these threats diminish.
KONY2012 has brought a spotlight on this issue, which is no bad thing but the oversimplification of a complex issue in a complex, fragile region has trivialised this and similar issues, failing understand the root causes of the problem and as a result its proposed solutions are futile.