Friday, 30 September 2011

UN Protection of Civilians


UN Peacekeepers are mandated with the protection of civilians among other things.  However, in many countries while peacekeepers work in difficult circumstances and contribute to maintain peace in conflict ridden countries their ideas around what does and does not constitute human rights abuse and protection of civilians from such abuses raises questions.  
In 2008 Save the Children UK conducted research and released a paper in May 2008 on child abuse by UN Peacekeepers in DRC, South Sudan, Haiti and Cote d’Ivoire.  In most cases sexual abuse of minors went unreported and unpunished, with children too scared to speak out and little happening to perpetrators when children did speak up.  In interviews, children said they engaged in prostitution, pornography, traded food for sex and were raped.
In September 2011 we uncovered new abuse against children by peacekeepers in Cote d’Ivoire.  The stories that some of the children (mostly girls) told were disturbing about being given food for sex or for showing their breasts. Younger girls claiming to be frustrated that they didn’t get the same amount of food as their breasts weren’t big enough - children who don’t know any other way to help their families and who don’t understand what this kind of abuse is need to be protected from it.
We informed the UN, both ONUCI (L'Opération des Nations Unies en Côte d'Ivoire) and UNICEF, of this issue and tried to support their investigation of it in order to protect the children as much as possible while the UN led investigation was ongoing. 
Apart from the fact that such abuse continues the more worrying part is the response of the UN to this.  In 2008 the report cited “endemic failure” on the part of the UN and others in responding to cases of abuse and recommended a review of reporting and review mechanisms.  In Cote d’Ivoire this month, this was again the most challenging part of the process.  Following the raising of these allegations numerous officials from ONUCI went to follow up in the camps with no concern for those who had the courage to raise the issue with our staff.  As the peacekeepers come from a number of different missions (Benin, Malawi, India, Morocco in this case) the UN protocol insists that each member country is involved in the investigation. 
In the interviews during the ONUCI investigation there was a team of 9 people (including representatives from the various sending countries, ONUCI leadership, child safety, officers, lead investigators etc) interviewed individual girls between 9 and 13 years is intimidating at the very least, unlikely to be able to maintain confidentiality and very unlikely to find the truth.  As the formal investigations continue Save the Children staff continue to support these communities and the children in particular. 
Sexual exploitation and abuse have long-lasting psychological and physical consequences including developmental and social problems, sexually transmitted infections such as HIV and as such psycho-social support is provided for these children.  Protection training is being conducted with the UN forces and once again we hope to be able to ameliorate this desperate situation that has such a huge impact on people who have been abused by the very people sent to protect them.
Here you can read the Save the Children 2008 report, No One To Turn To

Regenerating an Economy



Cote d’Ivoire is a lush country with tremendous agricultural potential.  There is sufficient rainfall for 3 agricultural seasons in the year and the majority of the land is available for cultivation.  It has been the world’s largest cocoa producer for many years.  

During the months of intense conflict in the west, due to the lack of food, many households resorted to consuming their seed stocks. Others lost all of their seeds and agricultural tools during looting or as they fled their homes. Others made the decision to sell their seeds for far less than market rates in order to move their families to safety.  Small scale producers who have traditionally had little bargaining power vis-à-vis larger market traders’ speculative practices have been particularly disenfranchised following these displacements.  The fact that the main cultivation season’s harvest was affected by the conflict coupled with the lack of inputs and the fact that many have missed the current planting season may lead to longer term food insecurity in the west. 
Save the Children and others responded to this situation through a Cash Transfer Programme.  This is an increasingly popular intervention in crises that affect vulnerable populations to enable them to make best use of local available resources to restart their livelihoods.  Cash programming provides households with the dignity that they deserve in choosing the kinds of food that they will consume in their households (as well as meeting urgent medical needs and paying school fees) and in deciding upon the right moment for them to go home and rebuild their lives.  This is often preferred to a standard food distribution in which families have no choice about what food they are given and often results in unwanted food being sold at low cost in markets. 
The amount of money given to each family was based on 75% of the calculation of average food needs for the month in order to reduce the risk of dependency.  Cash transfers happen on a monthly basis for a period of 3-5 months and are accompanied by training for those involved in both agricultural livelihoods and small scale business activities.  It’s a short term boost to families who lost assets in the conflict enabling them to get back on their feet.  
It has been great to see this working in practice and to see people begin to rebuild their lives after the crisis without the dependency of food distributions.  

Thursday, 15 September 2011

A Country in Turmoil


This blog is long overdue and I have backdated a couple of things I’ve been working on over the last month or so.  I have just completed 10 weeks of work in Côte d’Ivoire following the recent political and humanitarian crisis.  
Côte d’Ivoire was a leading economy in West Africa for 30 years post independence under the leadership of its first president, Felix Houphouet-Boigny.  Across the region it was conspicuous for its religious and ethnic harmony and its well-developed economy.  Since the political coup in 1999 the country has suffered a significant set back economically and the country remains divided.  
The second round of elections held in Côte d’Ivoire on 28th November 2010 resulted in both contesting candidates being sworn in as president of the country. Following months of negotiations to resolve the political crisis, heavy fighting erupted in the west and in Abidjan. This led the country back into a civil war and resulted in a reported 1,500 deaths and over one million people displaced.  The fighting ended in late April but the impact of it still remains and there is a lot to be done to bring Côte d’Ivoire back to the economic hub that it once was for West Africa.
The Battle of Abidjan in early April saw displacement across the city in densely populated areas affecting all education levels, skills sets, and social classes.  Economic sanctions targeting Gbagbo’s inner circle affected imports and exports and the closure of banks cut off the population from key financial resources. The income generating opportunities and purchasing power of virtually all Abidjanais were severely hampered during the weeks of fighting in the city.

Peace remains fragile and Mr Ouattara, a former deputy director of the IMF, is not yet entrenched. He managed to displace his predecessor, Laurent Gbagbo, whom he beat in the election by an official margin (endorsed by the UN, among others) of 54% to 46%, only because rebels loyal to him eventually swept down from the countryside; with help from a UN force spearheaded by the French, they then forced Mr Gbagbo out.
Côte d’Ivoire is still divided along a north/east-south/west fault line and while Outtara has promised there will be no impunity for anyone involved in atrocities during the conflict so far none of his own people have been arrested or detained and the government seems to be focusing on punishing the defeated. Several Gbagbo associates have been charged and the justice system is investigating the alleged economic crimes of his clan. There is no doubt about the seriousness of the charges against Gbagbo’s military and civilian allies before and during the crisis or the need for investigation. But no charges have yet been brought against supporters of the new president who it is alleged may also have committed serious crimes.  There needs to be space for political opposition or it remains likely that there could be renewed violence in pro-Gbagbo areas.