Tuesday, 21 February 2012

Aid and Accountability



In the humanitarian aid world, ‘accountability’ is a buzzword but it means very different things to different people.  And while there are systems for recognising the "rights" of beneficiaries and the obligations of agencies. The application of these is erratic and there are few legal frameworks capable of holding NGOs to account either for the funding we receive as grants and for the work that we do.  
While we clearly seek to ‘do no harm’, harm does sometimes occur and there is very little in the way of legal and regulatory frameworks governing our work and the countries, contexts and communities we tend to work in have very little ability to hold NGOs to account.  Our humanitarian principles may be noble and well intentioned but this means nothing if those whose lives we aim to better have in fact been made more vulnerable to disease or economic hardship.  When we do take time to think about accountability, too often it is those on the receiving end of "charity" who are forgotten.
In our refugee response that is going on near the border with Sudan there is a very real possibility of disease spreading through camps where a growing number of people are living.  As was seen in Haiti in 2010 the lack of sanitation and clean water combined with a high population density quickly leads to cholera.  A preventable crisis on top of an existing crisis resulted in local communities claiming that NGOs (and donors) didn’t react quickly enough to transform temporary shelters into permanent homes, or to provide access to drinking water and sanitation services. The response to the cholera outbreak was equally slow and devastating to many.  
In a camp like Doro in Maban where we are working, there are a dozen NGOs providing services.  The camp was designed to accommodate 25,000 people and yet there are currently 48,000 people living there because the over flow ‘Doro 2 camp is still being demined.  Save the Children are providing Child Protection and Education support and an assortment of other agencies are supporting, food aid, shelter construction, water provision, sanitation provision, health care etc.  Most of us have very little in the way of available funds and are still waiting for grant funding to come through for this response and as a result many of these interventions have been slow to start up, including our own. 
As the April 8th deadline for Southern Sudanese to leave the north looms closer these problems of overcrowding in refugee camp areas may well be compounded by the arrival of returnees and the dangers of slow response become more pressing.  We do need to remember that these people are the people we are working for and ensure that we are responding to their needs in a timely and efficient manner despite the constraints of the funding environment.

Friday, 10 February 2012

Feeding the Poor


It’s no secret that I’m not a fan of the World Food Programme (WFP); to qualify that statement I’m not a fan of much of the UN but more on that another time…  While the principle of giving food to starving people is clearly a good thing; food aid has become a billion dollar industry with WFP at the forefront of it.  
WFP comes under a lot of criticism from people like me and let’s be fair, they do fly us around the place a lot and they do do impressive logistics (in most places) but the principle of food aid and the way in which it is provided is of  great concern.
South Sudan has been receiving food aid from WFP for over 25 years and this is no mean feat given the lack of infrastructure, the long rainy season making many places inaccessible and the countless years of war.  In the early days, this food aid was dropped out of planes, these days it’s a bit more civilised with organised food distributions.    Clearly the single most important factor in the management of food aid is ensuring that the required food gets to the people who need it, at the time they need it, in the quantity they need it and for the period of time that they need it.  
It’s doesn't take a lot of common sense to see that such a long intervention raises questions about the dependency of the people here on food aid.  Food aid can easily undermine local markets and drive the price of farmer’s outputs down and it is well documented that prolonged delivery of food aid is likely to have a negative impact on the interrelationships between different wealth groups, where the poor labour for the wealthy and this natural mutually beneficial relationship is eroded when the poor become more dependent on food aid.  I appreciate that this is very simply put but all the same it is a valid point.
This week the Guardian reported that over £50m of World Food Programme resources have gone to Swiss based company Glencore International despite a commitment from the UN to buy food from "very poor farmers".
WFP rely on donations from UN member countries in the form of cash or gift-in-kind (another problem altogether which I’ll no doubt deal with another time) and buy up the rest of their stock and so it’s hardly surprising that WFP buy from such companies; they award a tender for food to the lowest bidder.  It’s also unsurprising that the lowest bidder at crisis times are large conglomerates who can plan their positions in the market to benefit at times of high volatility. Speculation on grain markets forces the prices up squeezing small scale producers out during times of global shortage and thereby driving more people into extreme hunger, perpetuating the need for the WFP who like many other UN agencies seem to have a need to justify their existence.  It is perhaps time for WFP to rethink their priorities and support local markets rather than corporate giants.