Wednesday, 14 March 2012

KONY2012 and its absurdity

A week ago, ‘Invisible Children’ released their KONY2012 video and it went ‘viral’ as they say, which in itself is quite remarkable; very rarely is the western world’s conscious so well awakened by an African conflict.  
I have been astonished by some of the positive comments on facebook and other fora about this and equally relieved by other comments in criticism of Invisible Children’s plan in response to the LRA crisis that spans across Northern Uganda, South Sudan, DRC and CAR.
I certainly don't claim to be an expert and others have written critical responses to the KONY2012 video.  This issue has made me sufficiently angry though that it has compelled me to put pen to paper.
Joseph Kony is a fugitive and maintains this existence through keeping a low profile, moving on foot through forests and areas that are severly underdeveloped and keeping people fearful of him.  He has rejected numerous peace deals and while his works are atrocious relatively speaking (in terms of people he has killed or abducted) he is no worse than many of South Sudan’s rebel leaders, yet he is internationally known, and feared and the media have perpetuated this. As Alex de Waal says, he has ‘an impressively high infamy-to-atrocity ratio testament to the effectiveness of terrorist advertising’.
Invisible Children’s campaign which advocates the use of American military ‘advisors’ to support the local armies of Uganda, South Sudan and Congo is somewhat deluded given successive military attempts to capture Kony over the years.  He has been under an ICC arrest warrant since 2006 and has so far evaded it.  The last time the Ugandan Army (with their colleagues, the Rwandans) entered Congo to catch the genocidaires hundreds of civilians were killed, villages were burnt and women raped.  
Since peace and stability began returning to northern Uganda over the last 6-8 years (when Kony left the area) reconstruction and reconciliation projects have been in place. Kony and his LRA have survived in this region principally because the people in these areas have reasons to distrust the national government and rule of law doesn’t extend this far.  Kony has moved out of northern Uganda as the country has stabilised but he remains active in South Sudan, CAR and DRC. 
I am certain that a man hunt for someone who has been driven from his own country, through the use of increase military spending across sovereign borders is not a beneficial solution to the problem of the LRA.  In the same way that the removal of Sadaam Hussein from Iraq did not bring peace, and the removal of Osama Bin Laden has not stopped Al-Quaida, stopping Kony will not stop the LRA unless something else changes in the region.  Kony has been driven from Northern Uganda, for the most part, by investment in infrastructure, stronger government interest and community development.  
The links between poverty and conflict are strong and economically independent,, educated, healthy people are much less likely to take up arms and fight.  If you have nothing to lose and everything to gain by fighting it’s a sensible option to take and surely the way to drive people like Kony to obscurity is to continue to develop investment in communities and their children, through education, through economic empowerment and development of social and physical infrastructure.  It’s a cliché but, by building stronger, more resilient communities that have access to basic services, many of these threats diminish.
KONY2012 has brought a spotlight on this issue, which is no bad thing but the oversimplification of a complex issue in a complex, fragile region has trivialised this and similar issues, failing understand the root causes of the problem and as a result its proposed solutions are futile.